"When the moon will explode or floats away, I'll lose the souvenirs I've made."
So I read the Annie Proulx short story, Brokeback Mountain, last night. It comes in it's own little hardcover that you can get from a bargain bin for $4.99. It's probably one of the most famous short stories in the last 20 years, and definitely one of the most talked about movies. But the controversy overshadows how well written the story really is.
It's not perfect. But nothing great is perfect. The characters are so clearly revealed and the interactions are significant and very little is hidden under the surface of the language. Unlike say, Cormac McCarthy, who revels in a phantasmagoria of logophillic hodge-podge, Proulx chooses to beef up certain phrases only if it can illuminate a little more what emotion she's trying to get us to feel.
Her best moments are the most clearly conjured. Two ranch hands holding each other near a cold sunlit riverbank. A man discover his true love's boyhood haunts and the place where he kept his treasures. These are the moments that break your heart most because they cast aside the issues of how we define our love and focus on the effects it has on a person. When she lets go of the reins and the story takes us so organically through the emotional tangles of these men, we care more about them.
The only part of the story where she makes it easy on herself and the characters is in the relationship they share with their wives. She makes the women unlikable to a degree enough that it seems fair that Jack and Ennis would want to leave them. It seems like she's sacrificing some authenticity in the characters in order to soften up the fact that the infidelity seems like a reasonable reaction.
It's a brave story, told in a big and charitable style that makes you really feel like you're there. You know enough about these men to feel sorry for them in how doomed they are. And you walk away wondering about the reality of the men who lived it. And hope that maybe someday we'll be ready in all the corners for inexpressible desire to be realized.
Chatboard (0)